In a theft case, your record can change the charge itself
In most criminal cases, a prior record affects the punishment. In a Texas theft case, it can change what you are charged with.
Taking something worth less than $100 is normally a Class C misdemeanor, punished by a fine. With one earlier theft conviction, the same act is a Class B misdemeanor that carries up to 180 days in jail. With two or more, anything worth less than $2,500 becomes a state jail felony.
Value is the other half of the grade. It is the fair market value at the time and place, not the original price, and amounts taken as part of one scheme can be added together into a single, higher charge.
So we treat a first theft case as a question about your record for years to come, not only a case to close. After you complete deferred adjudication for a first misdemeanor theft, the court generally must seal the record, and even a first misdemeanor theft conviction can later be sealed by petition. Both options depend on having no other conviction or deferred adjudication, which is why the first case matters so much.